Messianic Rabbi: The Problem with Paul

by | Jan 25, 2023 | Bible Study, Israel & Jewish Roots, Spirit-Led Living, Standing With Israel

Read Time: 3 Minutes 36 Seconds

I cannot tell you the number of conversations that I have participated in, or the number of sermons or Bible studies I have heard, where someone made the statement, “The problem with Paul is…” and then the person made a definitive statement of what they thought Paul said, did or taught wrong.

The bottom line is that when Christianity adjudicated the divorce proceedings between Law and grace, Paul was like the third wheel best friend of the couple who was supposed to choose who he was going to stay friends with: the ex husband or the ex wife.

However, Paul chose to stay friends with both, and his choice has caused a huge problem among Bible believers ever since. Paul’s choice to both be pro-Law and pro-grace has been a fly in the ointment of many “New Testament” scholars.

Because Paul never made the decision to choose between the ex-husband (Law) or the ex-wife (grace), pastors and teachers for 2,000 years have been making that choice for Paul and then justifying their choice by manipulating the writings of Paul to justify their position.

For example, one teacher might use Ephesians 2:8-9 to establish that Paul chose grace over Law:

“For by grace you have been saved through faith. And this is not from yourselves—it is the gift of God. It is not based on deeds, so that no one may boast.”

While another teacher might quote Romans 3:31 to prove that Paul continued to follow Torah and teach others to do so:

“Do we then nullify the Torah through faithfulness? May it never be! On the contrary, we uphold the Torah.”

The truth, however, is that the reason Paul never chose sides in the divorce between Law and grace is because Paul understood that the New Testament was never intended to be the divorce decree of Law and grace. Paul knew that Law and grace have an everlasting relationship and, in fact, are inseparable. Paul didn’t choose a side in the divorce because the divorce only took place in the minds and hearts of “scholars” who, for some reason, couldn’t comprehend the absolute and complete compatibility of Law and grace.

Paul understood that it was completely compatible to believe in the absolute and complete redemptive work of grace, while at the same time, Paul made the arduous and dangerous journeys to Jerusalem to keep the commanded Feast of the Lord. Paul believed there was complete harmony between trusting in the sacrificial offering of Yeshua for his redemption and continuing to make sacrifices in the Temple. Paul understood fully that a person’s eternal relationship with G-D wasn’t based upon circumcision of the flesh, yet he also understood the need to circumcise Timothy.

For nearly 2,000 years, believers in Messiah have been operating under the false assumption that the glass of faith either has to be half empty or half full, when the truth that Paul understood was that it is a faulty premise to believe that we must make a choice between half empty and half full. Paul understood that the glass of our faith is not either half full or half empty, rather our glass is both half full and half empty. Paul understood that the teachings of the Bible were never intended to cause us to make a choice between Law and grace; G-D’s Word emphatically teaches us to follow the example of Paul and embrace both Law and grace enthusiastically.

It is with this in mind that Paul wrote these words in Titus 2:11-12:

“For the grace of God has appeared, bringing salvation to all men, training us to deny ungodliness and worldly desires and to live in a manner that is self-controlled and righteous and godly in the present age.”

Notice that while Paul says that grace appeared and brought salvation to all men, he also says that grace will train us to deny ungodliness and worldly desires and to live in a manner that is self-controlled, righteous and godly. In other words, true belief in grace brings with it an obedience to Law.

So, it seems many people believe that there is a problem with Paul. However, the greatest problem with Paul doesn’t have anything to do with Paul or what Paul wrote. The problem is the false belief that Paul’s writings instituted a divorce or division between Law and grace. The truth is that Paul’s writings, along with the rest of the Bible, actually establish that the relationship between Law and grace is inseparable.

So, it may be that if we see a problem with Paul, then the problem is actually us.

Bring Charisma magazine home with a subscription today!

Eric Tokajer is the author of “Overcoming Fearlessness,” “What If Everything You Were Taught About the Ten Commandments Was Wrong?,” “With Me in Paradise,” “Transient Singularity,” “OY! How Did I Get Here?: Thirty-One Things I Wish Someone Had Told Me Before Entering Ministry,” “#ManWisdom: With Eric Tokajer,” “Jesus Is to Christianity as Pasta Is to Italians” and “Galatians in Context.”

CHARISMA NEWSLETTERS

Stay up-to-date with current issues, Christian teachings, entertainment news, videos & more.

The latest breaking Christian news you need to know about as soon as it happens.

Prophetic messages from respected leaders & news of how God is moving throughout the world. 


MORE FROM CHARISMA

Yes, Jesus Did Address Sexual Sin

Yes, Jesus Did Address Sexual Sin

Yes, Chris Bryant, Jesus really did address the subject of homosexuality, no matter how much you might want to twist the issue. After the Church of England recently set down an edict that forbid same-sex couples to marry but that each individual would receive "God's...

Influential Jesus-Believing Rabbi Issues Stern Warning for America

Influential Jesus-Believing Rabbi Issues Stern Warning for America

Rabbi Kirt Schneider, a Jewish believer in Jesus, warns that our culture will continue to go from bad to worse, just as Scripture says. "It's already too late," Schneider says. "The floodgates of darkness have been opened and there will be no global restoration or...

Get Ready, the Next Revival Will Be Very Messy

Get Ready, the Next Revival Will Be Very Messy

Many Christians pray for spiritual awakening, and that’s good. But I wonder if we realize how disruptive revival will be when it hits us like a tsunami. If you read accounts of previous revivals, three things become obvious: (1) revival requires a lot of work; (2)...

Breaking Free of the Spirit of Religion

Breaking Free of the Spirit of Religion

Recently, I was getting ready to leave in the morning when I suddenly had a vision. In this vision, I was taken into a room that appeared to be inside a funeral home. Everyone was dressed in black clothes and packed in this room, standing shoulder to shoulder and...

Take the Generational Curses in Your Life to Court

Take the Generational Curses in Your Life to Court

Have you been in a cycle of sin that, when looking deeper, your family line has battled over the years? A significant spiritual battle that many of us face is a cycle of familiar spirits, also known as generational curses. Habitual sin is often a product of an...

Beware of Satan’s Deceitful Imitations

Beware of Satan’s Deceitful Imitations

During the week as I drive to my office, I almost always turn on the local radio station and listen to the news. On a recent morning, one of the main stories being covered was about a well-known musical artist who was suing a lesser-known artist for imitating them on...

It’s Time to Drain the False Prophetic Swamp

It’s Time to Drain the False Prophetic Swamp

I believe there  are many more false prophets than true ones in America. I applaud Mario Murillo, who came out and exposed the wokeness of Christianity today. The "prophetic" swamp must be drained. The degree of goofiness and tomfoolery in the false prophetic camp is...

RECENT ARTICLES

Do You Follow God Out of Fear?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BTiiiTUQYKM&t=24s People are either saved by experiencing His goodness (Romans 2:4) or by the fear of being cast into hell (Jude 23). Jesus told us He is the only...
Outspoken Christian Actress Cindy Williams Dead at 75

Outspoken Christian Actress Cindy Williams Dead at 75

Cindy Williams, the hit actress known for playing Shirley Feeney on the sitcom "Laverne & Shirley," has died according to a statement released from her family. After battling a short illness Williams died at the age of 75. Williams was outspoken about her...

Cindy Jacobs: ‘God is Awakening and He’s Bringing Revival’

Cindy Jacobs: ‘God is Awakening and He’s Bringing Revival’

There is little doubt that Christian persecution is accelerating throughout the globe. People throughout the world are dying every day for the gospel of Christ, while others must endure great hardship because of their faith. Many Christians leaders have drawn a...

Prophecy: Get Caught Up in the Coming Revival Wave

Prophecy: Get Caught Up in the Coming Revival Wave

The Australian Prophetic Council met in early January to discuss, prophesy and weigh the word of the Lord for 2023. While not all individual words are captured here, there are key themes and major points that were established out of the mouth of many witnesses. Our...

Charisma Media archives

Pin It on Pinterest