Jews and The Passion

by | May 31, 2004 | Israel & Jewish Roots

Jews view the film through a tragic history of being blamed for “killing the Son of God.”
Mel Gibson’s new film The Passion of the Christ is well on its way to becoming the most controversial–and successful–film of 2004. The movie triggered a national debate about whether or not it is true to Scripture, historically accurate or excessively violent. I see all this discussion as a good thing. People–including Jews–are talking about Jesus!


But no issue that has arisen from this movie is more volatile than the charge that it is anti-Semitic. Is this accusation valid?


My response after viewing The Passion three times is no, the film is not anti-Semitic. And Mel Gibson is most certainly not an anti-Semite. However, I do have some concerns.


For one, I have heard some Christian leaders naively state that the movie will unite Jews and Christians. Quite the opposite is true. It has and will continue to polarize the two communities. This is because the 2,000-year-old controversy about whether or not the Jews truly did kill Jesus has been fanned again into a flame.


Consider the difference between how Christians and Jews each view the film.


Most Christians view The Passion through a scriptural worldview. They see through the lens of the film’s positive impact on their personal and devotional lives and its evangelistic potency.


Jews, on the other hand, view the film through a historical worldview. They see through the lens of a tragic history of 20 centuries in which they have been blamed for “killing the Son of God” and, as a result, have suffered terrible persecution in the name of Christianity.


This view was clearly illustrated by several Israelis with whom I watched the film at the National Religious Broadcasters conference. They were visibly angry when the movie was over.


When they saw Jewish children turning into demons who tormented Judas, they understandably misinterpreted this extrabiblical scene to represent a demonization of the Jewish people.


Another thing that troubles me is Gibson’s use of source material from the works of Anne Catherine Emmerich, a 19th century nun who authored notoriously anti-Semitic writings. Her influence in the film can be seen in Caiaphas, who is so vindictive that he follows Yeshua to His scourging to watch, and torments Him when He’s on the cross. (A high priest never would have been close to a dead or dying person on Passover; it would have made him ceremonially unclean!)


So where in the world did this portrayal come from? Not from the Scripture. It came from visions Emmerich claimed to have had.


Portions of a statement released by the Union of Messianic Jewish Congregations about the film underscore the importance of preventing the misuse of the Gospel texts when questions arise about the death of Yeshua:


“The Gospels teach that only elements of the Jewish leadership, in unity with Roman authority, were involved in the death of Yeshua. Certainly, this was not … the great majority of Jews, who did not at that time even live in Israel.


“The Bible teaches that … the sin of all humanity was the reason for [Messiah’s] crucifixion, and this was by the design of God. … Because of the history of Christianity, the Passion story must be presented without imputing blame upon the Jewish people as a whole for the sin of putting Yeshua to death.”


When journalist Diane Sawyer asked Gibson who killed Jesus, he responded, “We all did.” Right answer, Mel! In the movie his own hand pounds the first nail into Yeshua’s hand.


When Sawyer asked Gibson if he was anti-Semitic, he responded: “No, of course not. To be anti-Semitic is un-Christian, and I’m not.”


Like Gibson has done, let’s get these issues on the table and talk about them openly. As a Jewish believer in Jesus I welcome the opportunity.


But when you join in the discussion, please remember that The Passion of the Christ is not the story of the crucifixion of the “leader of Christianity.” It is the story of the greatest Jew who ever lived.

CHARISMA NEWSLETTERS

Stay up-to-date with current issues, Christian teachings, entertainment news, videos & more.

The latest breaking Christian news you need to know about as soon as it happens.

Prophetic messages from respected leaders & news of how God is moving throughout the world. 


MORE FROM CHARISMA

How Prophetic Evangelism Is Impacting Change in Today’s Culture

How Prophetic Evangelism Is Impacting Change in Today’s Culture

Dr. Candice Smithyman, host of Manifest His Presence on the Charisma Podcast Network, recently interviewed apostle Stacey Campbell, founder of Shiloh Global about how prophecy can impact today’s culture. Apostle Campbell is passionate about teaching young people and...

Joyce Meyer’s Daughter: ‘I Tried Until I Almost Died!’

Joyce Meyer’s Daughter: ‘I Tried Until I Almost Died!’

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xc14ip0XyOw Growing up as the daughter of Dave and Joyce Meyer, Sandra McCollom knew about God’s goodness and unconditional love. “At eight years old, I remember sitting on the floor as my mom shared her faith with me. That’s when I...

Prophet: 10 Essential Guardrails for Hearing God’s Voice

Prophet: 10 Essential Guardrails for Hearing God’s Voice

In the journey of hearing God's voice today effectively and accurately, you need the practical and personal work of the Holy Spirit. Jesus clearly told his followers that those who hear His words and put them into practice are wise! "Whoever hears these sayings of...

Prophetic Vision: Three Tables Are Set

Prophetic Vision: Three Tables Are Set

Recently as I was worshipping the Lord, I went into a vision where I could see I was in a dark and very deep valley. It was nighttime, and the valley was surrounded by tall mountains. On the top of each I could see the outlines of men and instinctively knew they were...

How Your Apostolic and Prophetic Worship Will Hurt the Enemy

How Your Apostolic and Prophetic Worship Will Hurt the Enemy

We are living in a time where it seems that dreams and visions are accelerating. The enemy fights against prophetic insight being poured out according to Joel 2:28-32. Numerous deliverance ministries have risen up to combat the ‘Pandora's box’ that was released in...

Is He a God of Wrath or a God of Love?

Is He a God of Wrath or a God of Love?

Do you think the God of the Old Testament is a God of wrath, and the God of the New Testament is a God of love? The truth is that God is the same throughout the entire Bible. His wrath and His love are revealed in both the Old and the New Testaments. So why, then, did...

How You Can Have a Perfect Heart

How You Can Have a Perfect Heart

Your heart is the most important part of you. It’s not only a physical organ that keeps your blood pumping, but when the Bible refers to the heart, it’s talking about who you really are. Each person has an inner and an outer life. There’s the person we show to...

RECENT ARTICLES

Cindy Jacobs Prophesies: The Lord Says, ‘Am I Not the Mender of Broken Hearts?’

I was just praying and asking the Lord, “How can I encourage you all today?” I know there are so many challenges out there, but this is what the Lord said to me. The Lord said, “There are some...
How the FBI Raid on Mar-a-Lago Is Spiritual Warfare

How the FBI Raid on Mar-a-Lago Is Spiritual Warfare

It's been a few days since the FBI raided President Donald Trump's home in Mar-a-Lago, and the Biden Administration has yet to explain to the American people why they did what's never been done in American history—the government raiding the home of a former president....

Why Partial Obedience to God is Disobedience

Why Partial Obedience to God is Disobedience

My husband had a saying for our children growing up. “Partial obedience is disobedience.” He wanted them to understand that doing half the plan would not get them the full reward. Another reminder we used to tell our kids was, “Don’t think about it, don’t hesitate,...

Pin It on Pinterest

[class^="wpforms-"]
[class^="wpforms-"]
[class^="wpforms-"]
[class^="wpforms-"]
[class^="wpforms-"]
[class^="wpforms-"]
[class^="wpforms-"]
[class^="wpforms-"]
[class^="wpforms-"]
[class^="wpforms-"]
[class^="wpforms-"]
[class^="wpforms-"]
[class^="wpforms-"]
[class^="wpforms-"]
[class^="wpforms-"]
[class^="wpforms-"]