Prop. 8 May Be Upheld

by | Mar 6, 2009 | Charisma Archive

TRaditional MarriageMarch 6, 2009 — Christian observers say they are encouraged about the fate of California’s Proposition 8 at the conclusion of oral arguments heard before the state Supreme Court Thursday.

“Of course, we can never be certain how a court will rule until the decision is actually issued, but today’s arguments were very encouraging for those who worked so hard to ensure the passage of Prop. 8,” said attorney Brad Dacus, president of the California-based Pacific Justice Institute.

Proposition 8 passed in November with 52 percent of the vote, overturning the state Supreme Court’s May ruling legalizing gay marriage. But supporters of same-sex marriage subsequently filed three separate lawsuits claiming the measure was not a constitutional amendment but a revision that should never have been put before voters. A constitutional revision requires a two-thirds vote of the state Legislature before it can appear on the ballot. (Read more about the case against Proposition 8.)

At Thursday’s hearing, several justices seemed skeptical of calling Proposition 8 a revision to the state constitution. “You would have us choose between these two rights: the inalienable right to marry and the right of the people to change their constitution,” said Justice Joyce L. Kennard, Time magazine reported. “You ask us to willy-nilly disregard the right of the people to change the constitution of the state of California. But all political power is inherent in the people of California.”

That was the view put forth by Kenneth Starr, who represented Proposition 8 supporters. “The issue before this iconic court has to do with the sovereignty of the people of California,” said Starr, dean of the Pepperdine University School of Law and a former United States solicitor general. “We have heard a lot about individual rights and suspect classification … But the Attorney General’s office points to one inalienable right, the right to marry. But the people, too, have an inalienable right to change their constitution.”

Only Justices Carlos R. Moreno and Kathryn M. Werdegar asked questions that indicated they might overturn the measure.

Chief Justice Ronald George appeared to suggest that Proposition 8 opponents really wanted to make it harder to alter the state constitution, which has been amended 500 times since 1911, Time magazine reported. But he said that was an issue to take up with the state Legislature and not with the courts.

The justices also seemed skeptical of Attorney General Jerry Brown’s argument that Proposition 8 should be overturned because it violates the inalienable right to marry, which is too important to be struck down by a constitutional amendment. But the justices asked how the court was to distinguish between rights that can’t be taken away and those that are subject to amendment, the Times reported.

Justice Ming W. Chin asked whether the state should eliminate the concept of civil marriage entirely, leaving only civil unions or domestic partnerships available to all couples, whether heterosexual or homosexual, PJI reported.

In a debriefing with California pastors, Andrew Pugno, who argued with Starr on behalf of traditional marriage supporters, said the court seemed likely to uphold Proposition 8.

“You saw the court pretty broadly looking skeptically at the idea that an individual right declared by the court could trump or be off-limits from the vote of the people,” Pugno said. “Ultimately at the end of the day the inalienable right of the people to amend their constitution should control the outcome. So the other side had its work cut out for them because the court seemed predisposed against it.”

Pugno said the court was equally skeptical of invalidating the 18,000 marriages licensed between June and November. “It really seemed like the court was really not looking at the law but just looking at emotion and kind of the politics and of the human element and saying this just doesn’t seem fair that we shouldn’t grandfather in some gay marriage because they were able to do it before the elections,” he said.

The court has up to 90 days to issue its ruling.

 

CHARISMA NEWSLETTERS

Stay up-to-date with current issues, Christian teachings, entertainment news, videos & more.

The latest breaking Christian news you need to know about as soon as it happens.

Prophetic messages from respected leaders & news of how God is moving throughout the world. 


MORE FROM CHARISMA

Prophetic Words: End of Year Prophecies to Guide You into 2023

Prophetic Words: End of Year Prophecies to Guide You into 2023

Chris Reed's Prophetic Word Over China: Unprecedented mass protests are unfolding right now across China. The country is seeing the largest pushback in decades, following their "zero COVID strategy" still in place today. China's Communist Party has continued to...

Declaring a Great Awakening Among Prodigals

Declaring a Great Awakening Among Prodigals

Read Time: 1 Minute 23 Seconds It’s a shocking statistic! More than 80 and up to 90% of children who grow up in church are leaving the church once they reach 18. Sadly, only 40% return, according to Focus on the Family. I believe, with prayer, we can defy those...

Bible Verse of the Day, Dec. 8th: Advent Season, Isaiah 11:1-10

Bible Verse of the Day, Dec. 8th: Advent Season, Isaiah 11:1-10

Isaiah 11:1-10 And there shall come forth a shoot from the stump of Jesse, and a Branch shall grow out of his roots. The Spirit of the Lord shall rest upon him, the Spirit of wisdom and understanding, the Spirit of counsel and might, the Spirit of knowledge and of the...

Marilyn Hickey: God Can Heal Your Emotional Wounds

Marilyn Hickey: God Can Heal Your Emotional Wounds

Read Time: 2 Minutes 2 Seconds Have you ever broken a bone? If so, you know what it’s like to go through a painful healing process. Consider what that might feel like in the spiritual realm. Sometimes we can get broken in various ways in life, but God wants to “set”...

COGIC Bishop Derrick Hutchins Sr. Dies at 65

COGIC Bishop Derrick Hutchins Sr. Dies at 65

Read Time: 1 Minute 59 Seconds Bishop J. Drew Sheard and the General Board of the Eastern Florida Ecclesiastical Jurisdiction of the Church of God in Christ announced Tuesday the death of one of its most beloved leaders, Bishop Derrick Hutchins Sr. Hutchins was 65....

RECENT ARTICLES

Don’t Criticize Charismatics

They are saying the charismatic movement is divisive. Whenever people get involved in the "new emphasis," there are disruptions in the status quo. Red flags go up. Lines are drawn. I would ask: What...
Jonathan Cahn Reveals the Mystery of the Molten Beast

Jonathan Cahn Reveals the Mystery of the Molten Beast

Read Time: 6 Minutes, 42 Seconds Is it possible that ancient entities known as "the gods" have returned to our world? Could these gods actually be the unseen movers and catalysts of what's happening in America and the world today? Could they lie behind the current...

Shining the Light of Jesus in Hollywood’s Darkness

Shining the Light of Jesus in Hollywood’s Darkness

Read Time: 3 Minutes 37 Seconds Most made-for-TV Christmas movies are like eggnog and sugar cookies—way too sweet, yet extremely addictive for a lot of viewers. But these Hallmark-style movies—the ones with predictable love stories that always end with jingling bells...

Prophecy: Goodness Is Following You, Turn and See

Prophecy: Goodness Is Following You, Turn and See

Read Time: 1 Minute 51 Seconds At a recent gathering where a member was struggling, I heard and declared by the Spirit of the Lord, “Goodness is following you, TURN and see; embrace His goodness in this moment and watch the shift!” There was an immediate shift and...

Man Who Spent 23 Minutes in Hell: You Came From God

Man Who Spent 23 Minutes in Hell: You Came From God

Read Time: 2 Minutes 25 Seconds If you search the phrase, “where does life come from?” the first explanation reads: “The origin of life is a result of a supernatural event—and readily arises from nonliving matter in short periods of time, today as in the past.” The...

Raise Your Praise!

Raise Your Praise!

These are the days that may leave you feeling defeated. You may be wondering when these present trials will end or how can you strengthen your faith for the battle as you wrestle against powers and principalities that come against you, in addition to the challenges...

Pin It on Pinterest